Gurgaon Man Forced to Buy Two Water Bottles for 98 Rupees After Restaurant Refuses Regular Drinking Water Wins 31,000 Rupees in Compensation
A resident of Gurugram has won an important consumer rights victory after taking a local restaurant to court for refusing to serve regular drinking water during a family dinner. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Gurugram held the eatery, Kafila Court Parking located near Rajiv Chowk, guilty of severe deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. For forcing the customer to buy packaged water bottles worth 98 rupees, the restaurant has now been ordered to pay a total of 31,098 rupees, including a refund, compensation for mental harassment, and legal expenses.
The incident took place on March 8, 2026, when complainant Mohit Jain visited Kafila Court Parking with his family for dinner. During the meal, he specifically requested the restaurant staff to serve regular drinking water. However, the staff allegedly refused his request and informed him that the establishment only served packaged bottled water. Left with no other option to quench his family thirst during dinner, Jain was compelled to purchase two 500-millilitre water bottles, for which 98 rupees was added to his final food bill.
Feeling aggrieved by the refusal to provide basic drinking water, Mohit Jain approached the Gurugram consumer commission to challenge the practice. In his complaint, he argued that denying free regular drinking water and forcing diners to buy expensive bottled water violated established consumer protection rules.
After reviewing the restaurant bill and examining the applicable legal rules, the three-member consumer commission, comprising president Sanjeev Jindal and members Jyoti Siwach and Khushwinder Kaur, ruled strongly in favor of the customer. The panel cited the guidelines issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority on July 4, 2022, which clearly state that hotels and restaurants cannot force consumers to buy bottled water or charge anything beyond the displayed menu prices and applicable taxes. Observing that the eatery had committed a blatant violation of these rules, the commission held Kafila Court Parking guilty of both deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice.
Under the final directions issued by the commission, the restaurant must refund the 98 rupees charged for the two water bottles along with 9 percent annual interest. In addition, the panel directed the eatery to pay 20,000 rupees as compensation for causing mental harassment, pain, agony, and economic loss, along with 11,000 rupees toward litigation costs.
The commission granted the restaurant 45 days to pay the entire awarded amount. It further warned that any delay beyond the 45-day deadline will attract a higher annual interest rate of 12 percent, and non-compliance could invite strict execution proceedings and prosecution under Section 72 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which carries penalties including imprisonment, a fine, or both.
For everyday diners and families eating out across Indian cities, this ruling serves as a clear reminder of their rights at restaurants and cafes. Establishments cannot compel customers to purchase packaged water by denying regular potable water, and consumers facing similar unfair billing practices can seek quick relief through state or national consumer helplines and district forums.
